Holiday Coffee Gift Guide: Fresh-Roasted Gifts for Every Coffee & Tea Lover

Posted by David Frutos on Sep 29, 2026

There's a special kind of panic that sets in around early December: the coffee lover on your list who already owns everything. What do you get them?

Our answer: give them coffee they'll actually drink. Fresh-roasted, small-batch coffee — or a beautiful loose-leaf tea — is the rare gift that's personal and practical. Everything below is roasted fresh the day it ships, because a gift should taste like you meant it.

For the Flavored-Coffee Lover

The Holiday Flavored Coffee Sampler is our top pick: three one-pound bags — Nutmeg Spice, Jack Frost, and Blizzard — for $55.99, in regular or decaf. Prefer single bags? Mistletoe Joe and Old-Fashioned Gingerbread are our seasonal one-pounders. And the Fall Flavored Coffee Sampler ($55.99) covers the whole autumn lineup — including Caramel Apple and Vermont Maple Pecan, now in single bags too.

For the Connoisseur

Hawaiian Kona Volcanic Estate Coffee — genuine 100% Kona, smooth and unforgettable. Jamaican Blue Mountain Estate — mild, sweet, legendary. Can't choose? The Jamaican & Kona Gift Set pairs them in one box.

For the Tea Drinker

The Gourmet Tea Sampler is an easy, thoughtful pick. Peppermint is practically a holiday requirement, and Pumpkin Spice Tea carries autumn into December. Add a Loose Leaf Infuser for a complete gift.

For the Hard-to-Buy-For

The Santa Pants Gift Set ($54.99) — Santa pants stuffed with Christmas Blend, Reindeer Crunch, and a Tortuga Rum Cake. Nobody else is giving it. Christmas Blend is tradition in a bag, and the Basket of Joy arrives looking like a gift already.

Stocking Stuffers

A Loose Leaf Infuser, seasonal teas like Peppermint, or a single bag of Mistletoe Joe — small gifts, big smiles.

Gifting Tips

Order early — everything is roasted to order, so allow extra days in December; order by mid-December for Christmas. When in doubt, choose a sampler. And remember the decaf drinkers — most of our coffees come in decaf too.